Editorial note: This article was originally published in the Knutpunkt 2026 book Seasons of Larp. It has been reprinted from there with the editors’ and authors’ permission. It has not been edited by Nordiclarp.org.
A first version of this article was originally written in French as a contribution to the francophone larp scene, where the typology of fun is used often but sometimes in very creative ways. I wrote it because last year, a friend who participates mostly in traditional medieval-fantasy larps in Belgium asked me to define what a Type 2 larp was. He had seen a larp presented as such and he wondered what it meant, exactly. His first assumption was that said larp aimed to provoke emotions, but then he backtracked: so-called “traditional” larps also provoke emotions. He thought: Is “Type 2 larp” a catch-all expression for all kinds of “non-traditional” larps? Is it a pompous way to define a casting-based and “well-designed” (his words) larp?
I asked around on francophone larp groups what people assumed “Type 2” meant and I was surprised by the diversity of interpretations in circulation. Someone explained: “Type 1 is when you feel the same thing your character feels, Type 2 is when you and your character are feeling different things.” Some went as far as to explain there was a hierarchy between different types of larps and larpers: “People usually start with Type 1 larps, as they are more accessible and you can usually participate with friends. But once you get used to this, you can move on to more sophisticated flavors. Type 2 larps go deeper, they are for more mature, more experienced players.” This, of course, provokes strong reactions to the expression “Type 2 larps” because it then feels condescending. I should point out that not everyone in the francophone larp scene is familiar with Nordic larp and it’s common for what you might call a “Nordic larp-inspired” larp to present itself simply as a “Type 2 larp.”
Few larp-related and easily accessible documentation on types of fun are still available online. In this article, I aim at achieving two things: First, I will try to clarify the typology of fun by putting it in its context and distinguishing it from other notions that might sometimes overlap or be confused with it. Secondly, I aim to document the diversity of uses of this typology, as well as some new or creative takes on it. By this, I hope to offer a reflection on how theories are crafted, appropriated in different contexts, and reframed.
Types of experiences
What is referred to as “Type 2” is an abbreviation of “Type 2 fun.” We are talking about the types of experiences that can be expected while larping. The Nordiclarp.org article indicates that the term “Type 2” was first used by Markus Montola in the Facebook group Larpers BFF in 2016. It stems from the outdoor adventure community, where it is used to describe experiences that are objectively unpleasant at the time but that would be enjoyed in retrospect, like working out until you puke or the final 300 meters to a peak that make you swear you hate alpine climbing. The typology, to put it simply, goes: Type 1 is fun the whole time, 5/5 stars, would recommend. Type 2 is challenging, uncomfortable or even painful at times, you might touch on your limits or even slightly exceed them, but afterwards you can expect to feel satisfied in some way. Type 3 is… We’ll come back to Type 3 later.
If we apply this to larp, we will experience Type 2 fun when we expose ourselves to a range of uncomfortable experiences that we would rather avoid in our daily lives. This can be on a physical level (such as hunger or sleep deprivation), an emotional level (exploring feelings including anger, grief, or anxiety) or a psychological level (such as high levels of stress, moral dilemmas, cognitive dissonance, poor mental health, etc.)

In contrast, Type 1 fun is enjoyable in real time. Type 1-oriented larps aim at giving you a good time. This can take various forms. You may find intellectual stimulation in solving puzzles or devising strategies. You may enjoy a banquet or singing in a group, making snippy comments at your companions, getting into brawl fights, falling in love, looking good in a costume, getting an adrenaline rush, or writing poetry during a retreat. If it makes you feel good, you’re probably having Type 1 fun. It is worth noting that what is enjoyable to some is not necessarily enjoyable to everyone. Some people enjoy horror movies, having a good cry every other weekend or getting a back massage that feels like it might break your body. The point is: you know you enjoy it.
Type I fun is an activity you’re sure you’ll enjoy, and you do. […] But Type II fun? That’s the sweet spot. It challenges you without putting you in danger — and it’s often uncomfortable but in ways that also make you feel alive. (Washington Post, 2022)
Whether it is appropriate to call these Type 2 experiences “fun” is open to discussion. For the sake of this article, the important part to focus on is that even though it might not feel good right away, it does lead to other forms of gratification, as Montola points out in his 2010 article ‘The positive negative experiences in extreme role-playing.’ Type 2 fun can, for example, satisfy a desire for intensity or exploration. It often offers memorable experiences that take us out of our daily lives, confront us with our limits, catalyze social bonds and make us feel alive. Type 2 can be cathartic in the sense that it allows us to experience, in a controlled environment, things that we would rather avoid in everyday life and which can, it seems, help us grow. This is, arguably, at the heart of transformative play.
How to use this typology?
A tension that runs through this typology is the question of what it applies to. Does it apply to experiences, to players, or to games? There is no unique answer to this, but they all bear slightly different meanings. Ericka Skirpan (2021), for example, argues that “recognizing your type [as a player] is a great resource to help you negotiate scenes, pick the games you are attending, fill out character surveys, and get the best experience you can for your own personality.” But she also stresses that you shouldn’t feel married to your “type”: it can change. Identifying what type of player you are would then be quite connected to identifying why your larp, an inclination towards the type of experience you aim for, and it would help to set boundaries in order to remain true to the experience you want.
Oftentimes, this typology is applied to games to say, for example: “this larp is a Type 2 larp.” I would argue against it, even though it is very common. It’s a shortcut and I think not a very accurate or even helpful one, as this typology describes a quality of experience, which might very well not be shared by everyone during a particular larp. When organisers use it in their statement of intent or design document to describe their larp, what it really means is: ”in this larp, players can expect a Type 2 experience.” The organisers are communicating about the experience they’re trying to deliver, but the organisers’ intentions are not a guarantee.
The players’ experience will not necessarily be homogenous within the same larp. The first episode of Clones (Belgium, 2016 ) was one of the most difficult experiences I’ve had in terms of Type 2 play. However, during the debriefing, I discovered that a significant number of players had experienced the same weekend as genuine Type 1 fun. Conscience (Spain 2024) is a larp that deals with dehumanization, oppression and violence (including sexual violence). When participating, it is very clear that we should expect to experience violent situations and rather uncomfortable, disturbing emotions connected to these themes. I was very surprised to realise afterward that I ended up having overall a quite feel-good experience thanks to a particularly beautiful love story that was central to my play.
Not all larp organisers seek to design specific experiences for their players. Sometimes, they are mainly aiming at creating an interesting environment in which players will have the freedom to create their own. This is particularly noticeable in larger scale events: when an important number of participants are gathered in the same larp, it becomes clear that not everyone necessarily experiences or seeks out the same thing. Players decide, to a certain extent, to steer the game in one direction or another. This typology remains very useful: saying for example “for me, Ragnarok this year was really a Type 2 experience” allows you to situate your experience in relation to others.
What Type 2 is not necessarily
In the context of the francophone larp scene, Type 2 is sometimes confused with other concepts that I would like to distinguish here.
Not all Type 2 experiences are “hardcore.” What we sometimes call hardcore larping is a way of engaging with the larp in a particularly intense way, by making the choice to simulate less than what is considered normal in a particular larp tradition. The threshold of what is considered hardcore will vary from group to group and time to time. In many larp cultures, Type 2 experiences are not considered hardcore. You can have experiences that are uncomfortable at the time at varying levels of intensity. Type 2 play can become a norm in itself within a community.
It can be tempting to conflate Type 2 play with the idea of “mature larp.” A larp with mature content may address themes or present content that is not appropriate for all audiences, such as certain types of violence, sexual content, nudity, or gore. What we mean by this is that a certain level of discernment is expected from participants to approach these themes maturely. It is clear that this sort of content is not strictly necessary to have a Type 2 experience. Type 2 is not a theme: it is a quality of experience.
What I sometimes hear in the use of the term “mature larp” is that you need a certain maturity as a larper to play this type of game. Indeed, Type 2 experiences can be overwhelming or disturbing – they can trigger complex emotions. They often require better emotional safety tools (e.g., a clear framework for calibrating, processing and debriefing these experiences), as well as better communication between players and with organisers. In this sense, they can be suitable for players who can make use of these tools. However, it is important to keep in mind that many people have started larping with these “Type 2-oriented games” and many more have been larping for decades without ever exploring those.1 Maybe this should be thought of as eating spicy food: some people seek it, others don’t, some people will enjoy it even if it systematically causes them to cry, others will take it without breaking a sweat – in any case, it’s good to have the information accessible on the menu so everyone can make informed choices.
Finally, it is sometimes implied that Type 2 experiences are more authentic, as if crying your eyes out after your loved ones murdered each other at your birthday party were the pinnacle of human experience, while enjoying a game of dice in a tavern would be superficial. The idea that suffering produces a deeper, truer, more authentic experience than pleasure should be seen as problematic. Some within the larp community question the temptation to #always_escalate to more drama, more provocation, more shock, more tears. Les Canotiers de Santeuil (France 2014, Eng. The Canoeists of Santeuil) is a game that could be described as “slow larping.” It aims to counter the idea that “les gens heureux n’ont pas d’histoire” (a French idiom meaning “happy people have no story”) by creating a low drama larp with characters that are normal people with engaging stories. Sandy Bailly defends the dignity of so-called “feel-good” play, notably in her presentation at Solmukohta 2024: “It’s not bad to feel good. The meaningfulness of slice of life and feelgood play.” See also “Finding the magic in the mundane” (Bailly and Kyhn, 2021), which argues that we don’t need big scenes or exceptional situations to have deep and meaningful experiences in larp. Exploring situations in which our characters flourish, experience intimate and beautiful relationships, or feel accepted and live their passion without feeling shame can also be very meaningful and moving for players.
Expand the typology?
The terms “Type 1” and ”Type 2” fun are commonly used by larpers, both in French-speaking countries and internationally. These terms communicate effectively about the type of experience we are having or want to live. We have so far touched a bit on how this typology means slightly different things depending on how it’s used; we will now take a closer look at ways in which it has been reappropriated and expanded on in sometimes creative ways.
Type 3
In the world of outdoor adventures, Type 3 fun is usually referred to as ”not fun at all, either during or after – a total disaster” (Cordes, 2009). However, the notion of Type 3 hasn’t been adopted so successfully by the larp community – particularly not in the francophone larp scene. Partly, I believe, because of the logical contradiction of assigning a type to fun that isn’t fun. There are recurring jokes that try to capture what a Type 3 larp might look like, as the KPTV 2025 clip “Enslaved by the Fish Orcs” illustrates.

Skirpan (2021) makes an interesting case for the Type 3 “fun” by making the typology into a sliding scale with regard to one’s boundaries and limits. Type 1 is when the player is playing within her comfort zone. We’re sliding from Type 1 to Type 2 when the player is affected by the discomfort or negative emotions out of character. This stretches the comfort zone but remains within the boundaries that the player sets for herself. This can be the place to experience some discomfort as a player, but within safe limits. We’re slipping into Type 3 when leaning too much towards pushing boundaries leads to actual damage – which should absolutely be avoided. In this reading, the three types of fun overlay partially with the zones of safety, challenge, and risk model described by Sarah Lynne Bowman and Kjell Hedgard Hugaas (2025), although it doesn’t correspond entirely.2 I’m not sure that’s how the types of fun model was initially intended, but it sure is an interesting way of looking at it – and one that justifies the existence of Type 3 according to its original definition.
Belgian Type 3
In Belgium, one take on Type 3 fun has been in use since at least 2021 – and it has nothing to do with the original typology that stems from the outdoor adventures. Type 3 in this context (I will call this “Belgian Type 3” to avoid confusion) is defined as a specific type of enjoyment that people who are a bit knowledgeable in larp theory experience when they appreciate a design. A form of intellectual stimulation, in short, something that could be translated as: “I see what you did there, it got me thinking, it inspired me!” One could come home from a larp and say: ”I didn’t have a lot of fun, I didn’t really have strong emotions, but it really engaged me on a meta level.” It can be the quality of the writing, the elegance of the scenography, the intelligence of the meta-techniques, something in the technical set up of the larp or in the way the workshops were conducted. Maybe people who experience a lot of this Type 3 fun position themselves more as art critics, their enjoyment being mediated through knowledge of the context and creative gesture. Seeking out Belgian Type 3 fun can be a perfectly valid reason to register for a larp and organisers can actively seek to design for this type of experience, for example by creating a game with a particularly elegant or experimental design.
Potpourri of fun
Some people in Belgium might have heard of Type 0.5 fun. It was popularized during a social activity at BEta Larp3 2023 in the quiz question “Which type of fun can you have at Les Rencontres de la Taille?” The correct answer was “0.5.” The organisers had been going around describing their larp as “a Type 0.5 larp” and by this, they meant to distinguish their larp from “Type 1 larps” in the sense that their larp “doesn’t even pretend to be cool.” It refers to the idea that they offer a game with no stakes and minimal constraints – a pretext for play, an excuse to spend time together – without trying to accomplish anything grandiose and with a fairly low emotional impact.
After some clarifying discussions with the initiators of the concept, I understand that this is a reaction to a prevailing discourse that (erroneously) associates “Type 1 larps” with “traditional heroic fantasy larps,” in which we would play heroes and therefore, we would be “cool.” In my view, however, the typology of fun is not an appropriate way to discern between different genres of games. Furthermore, Les Rencontres de la Taille’s description as a “Type 0.5 larp” illustrates beautifully how organisers can present their game in a certain way, but fail to deliver this specific experience to all players. After one session of this larp, a player told the organisers that “their game had definitely been Type 2” for him. My investigation into the Type 0.5 fun leads to the conclusion that it isn’t anything more than a joke, but one that has fruitfully forced people to ponder on their experiences, their design goals, and on the categories they use to describe them.
Finally, during BEta Larp 2024, Damien Bonnelle came up with the idea of Type 0 fun as something that can be experienced when you are at a larp but not (actively) engaging with the game. Don’t photographers, musicians, some helpers, or those that we might pejoratively refer to as “tourists” also have fun? Shouldn’t their experience be accounted for in some kind of typology? Participating in a larp can be an experience in and of itself, even when you are not actively engaging with the game. Social time, volunteering, cooking, playing music, participating as a family with young children, or even just existing in a beautiful location – all these things and many more are also ways to have fun at a larp, Bonnelle claims. One could say, to illustrate: “I’m participating in this larp mostly to camp out with my friends by the lake, it’s really Type 0 for us. I won’t be bothered with the full orc costume this time!” If we adopt Bonnelle’s idea, Type 1 fun would be reframed as applying to positive experiences lived through interacting with the game, while Type 0 would occur outside of it. This changes the original definition of Type 1 quite a bit. But after all: who decides what the correct use of these concepts is?
Conclusion
In this article, I have tried to achieve two things. First, to clarify a set of concepts – the types of fun – by distinguishing between them and replacing them in their context. Secondly, to document some new or creative uses of them. To be clear: while Type 1 and Type 2 fun are quite widely used in the larp community and beyond, the other types of fun mentioned here are more anecdotal, used in a range of different ways (Type 3), only by a few initiates (Belgian Type 3 and Type 0.5), or are even completely emerging ideas (Type 0). I believe it is interesting to try to define the experiences we seek or live, and certain additions to the original typology make it possible to highlight the diversity of experiences that larp can offer (Type 0 and Belgian Type 3).
Most theories we consider canon today were once an enthusiastic conversation in a bar, or any other type of social space (be it virtual.) They have been passed on by several people and then written down at some point, they have travelled from one larp scene to another and they have been affected by the difficult trial of translating culture. These concepts we’re crafting, they can help us to communicate with each other (our feelings, our intentions, our thoughts, what is important to us) and they give us a chance to connect and be understood. That is, at least, if we go through the trouble of reaching out, explaining ourselves, and building something that might become a common language.
Ludography
Clones (2016–2023) Belgium, GaRou ASBL http://clones.be
Conscience (2024) Spain, NotOnlyLarp https://conscience.notonlylarp.com/
Les Canotiers de Santeuil (2014) France, Les Amis de Miss Rachel
Les Rencontres de la Taille (2024) Belgium, Midnight Project
Ragnarok (ongoing campaign) Belgium, Ragnarok ASBL https://ragnaroklarp.be/
Si Qua Fata Sinant (2023) Belgium, La team Sangria chez Rôle https://siquafatasinant.eu/
Ük Egsdiin (2025) Belgium, Eggrégore ASBL
Bibliography
Bailly, S. (2024) “It’s not bad to feel good. The meaningfulness of slice of life and feelgood play” [talk]. Solmukohta 2024. Tampere.
Bailly, S. & Kyhn, M. (2021) “Finding the Magic in the Mundane” In Book of Magic: Vibrant Fragments of Larp Practices, edited by Kari Kvittingen Djukastein, Marcus Irgens, Nadja Lipsyc, and Lars Kristian Løveng Sunde. Oslo, Norway: Knutepunkt.
Bowman, S. & Hugaas, K.H. (2025) “Philosophies of Psychological Safety in Analog Role-playing Game Discourses” In International Journal of Role-Playing (16), 11–33.
Brind, S. et al. (2025) “Enslaved by the Fish Orcs”, KPTV (50m50s). Available at: https://vimeo.com/1069013052?fl=pl&fe=sh#t=50m50s
Bross (2014) “Les Canotiers de Santeuil”, Electro-GN. Available at: https://www.electro-gn.com/8907-les-canotiers-de-santeuil
Cordes, K. (2009) “The Fun Scale”, Kelly Cordes. Available at: https://kellycordes.com/2009/11/02/the-fun-scale/
Kannasvuo, S., Kevätkoski, R. & Leppä, E. (2021) “Slow Larp Manifesto” In Book of Magic: Vibrant Fragments of Larp Practices, edited by Kari Kvittingen Djukastein, Marcus Irgens, Nadja Lipsyc, and Lars Kristian Løveng Sunde Oslo, Norway: Knutepunkt.
Montola M. (2010) “The positive negative experience in extreme role-playing”, Nordic DiGRA (Authors & Digital Games Research Association).
Nordiclarp.org (n.d.) “Hardcore”, Nordic Larp Wiki. Available at: https://www.nordiclarp.org/wiki/Hardcore
Nordiclarp.org (n.d.) “Type 2 fun”, Nordic Larp Wiki. Available at: https://www.nordiclarp.org/wiki/Type_2_fun
Skirpan, E. (2021) “What’s Your LARPing Type of Fun?”, The Space Between Stories. Available at: https://thespacebetweenstories.com/2021/10/01/whats-your-larping-type-of-fun/
Strout, E. (2022) “What is ‘Type II fun,’ and why do some people want to have it?”, The Washington Post, 24 March. Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2022/03/24/what-is-type-2-fun/
This article is republished from the Knutpunkt 2026 book. Please cite it as:
Hoekendijk, R. 2026. ‘Types of Fun, Flavors of Experiences.’ In Seasons of Larp eds. Erlandsson, A., Svanevik, M., Holkar, M., and Brind, S. Gothenburg. Knutpunkt.
- This might sound very trivial when you are reading this in the context of Nordic larp, but in more local larp scenes, this is important to keep in mind. ↩︎
- The zones of safety, challenge, and risk model provides “a spectrum approach between more comfortable and riskier play, using both numbers and colors to indicate the level of risk, with Zone 1 (Green) referring to one’s comfort zone, Zone 2 (Yellow) referring to one’s growth edges, and Zone 3 (Red) referring to high-risk brink play” (p.16). Zone 3 (Red) is described as being at the edge of “too much,” but some players might still choose this sort of play. It is noted that: “such experiences can be unpleasant or even disturbing in games and yet highly valuable learning experiences” (p.17). Undoubtedly, this corresponds to the definition of Type 2 fun. Type 3 fun is definitely supposed to be placed outside the range of positive experiences, as Skirpan (2021) insists: “Type 3 is not fun. It is pure misery during the whole damn thing. The goal in sports, and in larping, is NEVER to get yourself stuck in a Type 3 experience.” ↩︎
- BEta Larp is the Belgian mainly francophone but international leaning annual larp conference. http://beta.larp.be/ ↩︎

